Damn it Jeremy, YOU WIN THE PRIZE!!!!!!
After putting the cylinder back down, I assembled the saw, and it still would not start. So based on all the comments, I replaced the coil. When I saw fuel coming out the muffler, and I still did not get a pop, I had to just put it down and walk away for a while. As I thought on it, Jeremy's comment seemed like the only logical answer.
When I pulled the flywheel nut last time I must have just checked that the space between the flywheel & key was correct, but that does not mean anything. I pulled the flywheel today, and the key is sheered, and was off by almost 180 degrees.
Thanks for the advice Jeremy, at least I know what it is now and can stop going crazy!!!