High Quality Chainsaw Bars Husqvarna Toys Hockfire Saws

Whats on the Grill or Smoker?

Definitive Dave

Piss Rev Mafia Member
GoldMember
Local time
8:20 PM
User ID
297
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
5,194
Reaction score
34,222
Location
Central Ohio
Country flag
Hey Guys, I tried to make my way through this whole thread but by page four I was drooling on my self.

My propane grill is six years old stainless steel from Lowes and looks great except the tubes inside are rusted out pretty bad, three of the five are totally crumbled away.
Suggestions for a gas grill that would last forever, cook evenly, clean up easily, etc.?
Also if i wanted a smoker so I didnt have to cook chickens from Ross in my oven, something great and reliable that works unattended?

Ill go back to drooling
thanks in advance
Dave
 

huskihl

Muh fingers look really big
GoldMember
Local time
8:20 PM
User ID
360
Joined
Dec 31, 2015
Messages
23,111
Reaction score
147,651
Location
East Jordan, MI
Country flag
Hey Guys, I tried to make my way through this whole thread but by page four I was drooling on my self.

My propane grill is six years old stainless steel from Lowes and looks great except the tubes inside are rusted out pretty bad, three of the five are totally crumbled away.
Suggestions for a gas grill that would last forever, cook evenly, clean up easily, etc.?
Also if i wanted a smoker so I didnt have to cook chickens from Ross in my oven, something great and reliable that works unattended?

Ill go back to drooling
thanks in advance
Dave
The Traeger pellet smoker/grill's seem to be popular here. Pretty much set it and forget it. Never used one myself, but @USMC615 should be able to shed some light.
 

Dub11

Saw R skeery
GoldMember
Local time
7:20 PM
User ID
2014
Joined
Oct 21, 2016
Messages
34,583
Reaction score
147,065
Location
Kansas
Country flag
Hey Guys, I tried to make my way through this whole thread but by page four I was drooling on my self.

My propane grill is six years old stainless steel from Lowes and looks great except the tubes inside are rusted out pretty bad, three of the five are totally crumbled away.
Suggestions for a gas grill that would last forever, cook evenly, clean up easily, etc.?
Also if i wanted a smoker so I didnt have to cook chickens from Ross in my oven, something great and reliable that works unattended?

Ill go back to drooling
thanks in advance
Dave

Those parts on your grill are a wear item.

And a Treagor or a Green Mountain smoker are tops
 

srb08

Doesn't play well with others
Local time
7:20 PM
User ID
1905
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
2,522
Reaction score
8,846
Location
Mid Mo
Country flag
Hey Guys, I tried to make my way through this whole thread but by page four I was drooling on my self.

My propane grill is six years old stainless steel from Lowes and looks great except the tubes inside are rusted out pretty bad, three of the five are totally crumbled away.
Suggestions for a gas grill that would last forever, cook evenly, clean up easily, etc.?
Also if i wanted a smoker so I didnt have to cook chickens from Ross in my oven, something great and reliable that works unattended?

Ill go back to drooling
thanks in advance
Dave
As Dub 11 said, the burners are replaceable and pretty inexpensive. You're going to have to occasionally replace burners, no matter what grill you buy.
If you want a new gas grill, look at a Weber. I've got a Genesis that I've had for five years. It gets a lot of use and still performs as well as when it was new. When you get into high end gas grills, the law of diminishing returns kicks in pretty quickly.
If you want a smoker that takes care of itself, you either have to go electric or pellet. Charcoal smokers require a bit of baby sitting. Gas is better but you still need to check on them occasionally. In windy conditions, they can be a pain to get regulated. Electric smokers do a good job and are truly, set it and forget it.
Pellet smokers are the cats ass but a good one ain't cheap.
Jason, @USMC615 will chime in shortly and give you the low down. He has a Traeger pellet grill/smoker, Smoke Hollow gas smoker and a Weber charcoal grill/smoker.
I have a Smoke Hollow at the moment that does a good job but a Traeger is going to be joining the outdoor kitchen in the next couple of months.
Good luck, whatever direction you decide to go.
 

Dub11

Saw R skeery
GoldMember
Local time
7:20 PM
User ID
2014
Joined
Oct 21, 2016
Messages
34,583
Reaction score
147,065
Location
Kansas
Country flag
Came three to a pack, almost bought two packs so I would have an even number but I am relatively new to smoking and didn't want to risk ruining too much meat.

I about the worse you can donis dry it out. I still do it half the time lol
 

amberg

Pinnacle OPE Member
Local time
8:20 PM
User ID
1736
Joined
Aug 23, 2016
Messages
2,874
Reaction score
8,241
Location
Va.
The daughter wanted burgers and dogs on the grill today, when she got home for summer break, so I grilled up some frozen burger patties and dogs. And mama made some tater salad to go with them.
 

Attachments

  • 100_1695.JPG
    100_1695.JPG
    183.6 KB · Views: 10

USMC615

Fapper Fi
GoldMember
Local time
8:20 PM
User ID
976
Joined
Mar 1, 2016
Messages
21,197
Reaction score
114,018
Location
Mid-Georgia
Country flag
@Definitive Dave...would absolutely agree with Steves', @srb08, previous post above (post #965). If going stainless and gas, the Genesis series from Weber are fine grills. If wanting to go with a pellet smoker/grill, the Traeger Pro 34 I bought is a fine smoking/grilling machine. The best pellet smoker I've ever fooled with. But be warnerd if going with the Pro 34...I've got about $1200 tied up in mine with the optional bottom shelf that sits btwn the legs for pellet storage, etc...and the large front folding shelf, that I think is an absolute must. There are certainly cheaper Traeger models and other pellet smokers out there that are good as well. I decided on the Traeger Pro 34 for the volume of groceries I can get on both the racks (can probably squeeze ten to twelve 8lb Boston Butts on it at one time, for an idea of what it'll hold). My Smoke Hollow 44" is a nice gas smoker...btwn the seven racks in it, I can smoke 42 half-chickens at one time, or approx 24-25 racks of baby back ribs at one time (one rack can hold 7 racks on edge with the way it's designed, then another 3 racks of ribs flat, across 6 other racks)...give you an idea of the quantity it'll hold. I've got less than $350 tied up in the Smoke Hollow 44" with my mil discount from Home Depot. I've got a Weber Performer as well and its been a fine grilling/smoking machine...I did buy the optional rotisserie ring and spit rods as well as a set of rib racks for it that drive off the motor/spit rod setup. Also have an ol' school big Brinkmann charcoal grill as well.

Hope this helps you a little Dave!
 
Last edited:

amberg

Pinnacle OPE Member
Local time
8:20 PM
User ID
1736
Joined
Aug 23, 2016
Messages
2,874
Reaction score
8,241
Location
Va.
Really hard for me to wait, bacon finally out of the cure and into the first cold smoke. only 3 more smokes to go!!!
Damn ,I am hungry!! I hope to be eating bacon by Sunday morning!
 

Attachments

  • 100_1701.JPG
    100_1701.JPG
    132.4 KB · Views: 7
  • 100_1703.JPG
    100_1703.JPG
    151.8 KB · Views: 7
  • 100_1704.JPG
    100_1704.JPG
    89 KB · Views: 7

stihl_head1982

Here long time
Local time
8:20 PM
User ID
168
Joined
Dec 24, 2015
Messages
4,153
Reaction score
14,549
Location
USA
Country flag
@Definitive Dave...would absolutely agree with Steves', @srb08, previous post above (post #965). If going stainless and gas, the Genesis series from Weber are fine grills. If wanting to go with a pellet smoker/grill, the Traeger Pro 34 I bought is a fine smoking/grilling machine. The best pellet smoker I've ever fooled with. But be warnerd if going with the Pro 34...I've got about $1200 tied up in mine with the optional bottom shelf that sits btwn the legs for pellet storage, etc...and the large front folding shelf, that I think is an absolute must. There are certainly cheaper Traeger models and other pellet smokers out there that are good as well. I decided on the Traeger Pro 34 for the volume of groceries I can get on both the racks (can probably squeeze ten to twelve 8lb Boston Butts on it at one time, for an idea of what it'll hold). My Smoke Hollow 44" is a nice gas smoker...btwn the seven racks in it, I can smoke 42 half-chickens at one time, or approx 24-25 racks of baby back ribs at one time (one rack can hold 7 racks on edge with the way it's designed, then another 3 racks of ribs flat, across 6 other racks)...give you an idea of the quantity it'll hold. I've got less than $350 tied up in the Smoke Hollow 44" with my mil discount from Home Depot. I've got a Weber Performer as well and its been a fine grilling/smoking machine...I did buy the optional rotisserie ring and spit rods as well as a set of rib racks for it that drive off the motor/spit rod setup. Also have an ol' school big Brinkmann charcoal grill as well.

Hope this helps you a little Dave!

Excellent advice.
If Dave want's to smoke meat with little human effort he is certainly gonna want a pellet grill/smoker. Smoking takes time and if you want good results you are going to have to attend to it at times. Another option is an electric smoker (with your requirements in mind). After looking at the capacity of this Traeger Pro 34 -- all I can say is WOW!
 
Last edited:
Top