I don't doubt that, but I think you are missing something I said. I think it depends on the saw, and porting on that saw.
I think it is a mistake to presume that because far more muffler opening worked on one saw that it will work on all of them. IMO, it is more likely to work on a ported saw, and less likely on a non ported one. I also think the timing #s play a role.
And not that I like to quote that AH (starts with a J), but he said that some of his saws lost power if the muffler was opened too much.
I think you are judging too quickly.
The Cross MMWS cylinders on my Asian twins were as close to identical as any two cylinders (OEM or AM) I have ever seen (my other two Cross cylinders were both different than these and themselves). I think these two were made back to back.
The only difference in assembly was the muffler baffle and outlet. Twin 2 was more aggressive, and I expected it to run stronger. When I put them both to wood, I was pleased with Twin 1, but not Twin 2.
Although about everyone told me it was not the muffler, I ordered another one and modded it less. I am now very happy with how Twin #2 runs. Don't know what else to say.
Mike, I like you , so please dont take this wrong ................ here goes
Tune is everything
you have said here before that you tune to a certain rpm
Thats not the way to find the most power in a saw
I dont believe that the results you get are wrong, but I do believe you go about it wrong, and get the wrong results.
Tune your saw in the wood for max rpm, with a tach.
You will see a difference.
Ask anyone that was at the Ct GTG ............ everyone except Dan thought my muffler modded new 395 was ported
It only had a HUGE bulls nose muffler mod.
It idled fine, didnt hesitate when you nailed it, and had mounds more power than a stock 395 ......... heck, it was just behind the ported ones.
I did that (along with running 12.5:1) on purpose. That purpose was to have guys wake up to the internet crap that they have been chewing on for too long.
So what happens when you cant adjust out the carb with a big muffler mod ?
You need more fuel, thats what.
PM me for more if you want Mike, but you can't just close off to changing one thing when you have left soooo much on the table
Could of gone bigger.
I tried, but I think keeping the brake operational was the best way.
I am considering cutting and TIG welding something on the other side ......... going to have to play with that brake handle to do it though
Kevin, if I had the talent, I'd make em like that! But seriously, some tests would be nice.
And don't you think those tests have already been done ?
Why would anyone go through the pain of splitting a NOS 395 muffler, cutting out the baffles, TIG welding on TWO 1.25" outlets and TIG welding the muffler back together ............. then bring that contraption (without timing advance or porting) to a GTG and tell everyone to run it with 404 and an 8 tooth on a 25" setup ?
Tests have been done Mike ............ you have a group of guys that you can ask, you have a bunch of resources at your fingertips ............. why are you believing the myth ?