I've adopted a "wait and see" approach to these situations. I've been on the forums longer than most, and was a member of AS before it was even Arboristsite (previously, it was an internet bulletin board, before they had forum software of any kind).
Many years ago, a thread was started about me supposedly sending out a "rebuilt saw" that was not really rebuilt. Some guys got into the thread and rabidly defended me, some others said I was the biggest POS ever. In the end, it turned out that another member sold and send out the saw - a member whom I never had any dealings with or even knew. They lived somewhat in my area but were about three hours away. That experience taught me that there's always a lot more to the story when a thread actually gets created about it. I think the only thing Wade did wrong here was rush in to defend the guy without having the back story, which is no different than rushing to slam a guy without having the back story.