High Quality Chainsaw Bars Husqvarna Toys Hockfire Saws

Not So Pro 3

Mastermind

Chief Cat Herder
Staff member
Yearly GoldMember
Local time
8:44 PM
User ID
4
Joined
Dec 3, 2015
Messages
52,557
Reaction score
350,090
Location
Banner Springs Tennessee
Country flag
Happy Thanksgiving guys!


Question for you guys who have animals...
As I sit and watch for deer, but see none, I've been thinking of how after a number of years the deer punched holes through the rubber liner in the water holes I dug.
I'm thinking of simply replacing with stock tanks.
Is one better than the other as far as galvanized, structural foam (rubbermade)Rubbermaid, etc?
I'd set them on concrete blocks and then just fill in the old water holes.
I'm looking at 250-300 gallon (ish).
I have had a 100 gallon rubbermaid tank for years. Never had a problem with it.
 

Only the Tony

Hiding in the back of the class.
Yearly GoldMember
Local time
8:44 PM
User ID
958
Joined
Feb 27, 2016
Messages
3,372
Reaction score
26,014
Location
SW MO
Country flag
Happy Thanksgiving guys!


Question for you guys who have animals...
As I sit and watch for deer, but see none, I've been thinking of how after a number of years the deer punched holes through the rubber liner in the water holes I dug.
I'm thinking of simply replacing with stock tanks.
Is one better than the other as far as galvanized, structural foam (rubbermade)Rubbermaid, etc?
I'd set them on concrete blocks and then just fill in the old water holes.
I'm looking at 250-300 gallon (ish).
How long are you going to keep water in them throughout the year? With your cold weather, if you don't drain or bury when you get to long freezing periods you will have to worry about splitting the sides. That said I have kept minnows in one in the yard and the ground contact has kept the last 6 inches from freezing solid until it warms up. We get about a week or two of negative mornings to teens afternoon, but no long, can't find your pecker because it retreated too far, stretches of cold.
I have had a 100 gallon rubbermaid tank for years. Never had a problem with it.
You don't have the weather that makes you want to move and question your sanity for living there from November to March.
 

Loony661

462’s 4-LIFE
Yearly GoldMember
Local time
8:44 PM
User ID
2584
Joined
Feb 4, 2017
Messages
6,954
Reaction score
47,256
Location
Winona County, MN
Country flag
Happy Thanksgiving guys!


Question for you guys who have animals...
As I sit and watch for deer, but see none, I've been thinking of how after a number of years the deer punched holes through the rubber liner in the water holes I dug.
I'm thinking of simply replacing with stock tanks.
Is one better than the other as far as galvanized, structural foam (rubbermade)Rubbermaid, etc?
I'd set them on concrete blocks and then just fill in the old water holes.
I'm looking at 250-300 gallon (ish).
Ed, these are a big hit around here:

A buddy of mine is a dealer and installs them on people’s land all the time.
 

redline4

I'm huge in Japan
Local time
8:44 PM
User ID
5593
Joined
Mar 12, 2018
Messages
13,273
Reaction score
112,288
Location
Rosholt Wisconsin
Country flag
How long are you going to keep water in them throughout the year? With your cold weather, if you don't drain or bury when you get to long freezing periods you will have to worry about splitting the sides. That said I have kept minnows in one in the yard and the ground contact has kept the last 6 inches from freezing solid until it warms up. We get about a week or two of negative mornings to teens afternoon, but no long, can't find your pecker because it retreated too far, stretches of cold.

You don't have the weather that makes you want to move and question your sanity for living there from November to March.
Ideally through the end of November, but that won't always happen. Sometimes it's 40, sometimes it's 2 degrees.
Ed, these are a big hit around here:

A buddy of mine is a dealer and installs them on people’s land all the time.
Those look nice but that msrp kind of scares a simple oil changer from Wisconsin..
 

Lnk

Stock Chainsaws do not suck!
Local time
9:44 PM
User ID
19702
Joined
Oct 12, 2021
Messages
6,978
Reaction score
39,659
Location
East, TN
Country flag
Happy Thanksgiving guys!


Question for you guys who have animals...
As I sit and watch for deer, but see none, I've been thinking of how after a number of years the deer punched holes through the rubber liner in the water holes I dug.
I'm thinking of simply replacing with stock tanks.
Is one better than the other as far as galvanized, structural foam (rubbermade)Rubbermaid, etc?
I'd set them on concrete blocks and then just fill in the old water holes.
I'm looking at 250-300 gallon (ish).
If you are going to bury something, I would get an ibc tote, cut it to suit. Refilling is going to be your problem. Do you have a way to run water or carry it to refill? Metal stock tanks are fine without ground contact, but pretty expensive compared to a tote. Just my $.02
 

redline4

I'm huge in Japan
Local time
8:44 PM
User ID
5593
Joined
Mar 12, 2018
Messages
13,273
Reaction score
112,288
Location
Rosholt Wisconsin
Country flag
If you are going to bury something, I would get an ibc tote, cut it to suit. Refilling is going to be your problem. Do you have a way to run water or carry it to refill? Metal stock tanks are fine without ground contact, but pretty expensive compared to a tote. Just my $.02

I have an IBC tote I put in the back of the truck for refills when needed.
This year was so dry and with the holes in the liner, I couldn't keep up.
I don't think I'll bury it. Just set something up on block to level it and be done.
 

Loony661

462’s 4-LIFE
Yearly GoldMember
Local time
8:44 PM
User ID
2584
Joined
Feb 4, 2017
Messages
6,954
Reaction score
47,256
Location
Winona County, MN
Country flag
Those look nice but that msrp kind of scares a simple oil changer from Wisconsin..
Gotta pay to play they say. I hear ya though, they certainly aren’t cheap. But they work. They hold water and do so more naturally than a tank above ground. You could easily work these into your existing pond sites with your skid steer to shape the ground accordingly.
 
Top