Aluminum wedges were the cat’s meow back in “the day,” which is to say shortly before I started working in the woods. Plastic wedges were too soft and expensive at the time to really be any good, which is interestingly the opposite of today. They won’t wreck a saw chain if you hit one, and they are fairly durable to beat on if you can square up the pole if your axe with the wedge.
Today the best wedge on the market, IMO, is the K&H Redhead. Lots of lift for the length of their wedges, and their wedges stack beautifully. Their triple taper wedges are great too, and even stack okay back to back, even if they’re more of a bucking tool than a felling tool, at least as I was taught. The biggest thing with them is to hit them square with something that will hit the whole length of the wedge face, like a big flat head axe. My wedge beater has a five pound head and weighs about six pounds overall. A maul will obliterate a plastic wedge no matter the brand.
I haven’t had any luck with stacking the Hardhead wedges. It seems like they pop right out when stacked, and eventually the steel insert cracks its way out of the end, which sucks.