Well I did some more forensic work on this carb today. And I also looked over the other one that does the same thing. Internally they are very different. The one from Huztl looks exactly like the genuine Walbro internally, except for a couple of differences. Those being a 0.54mm main jet (instead of the OEM 0.64mm) and a different high speed screw. There is definitely a gouge or even a crack in the main nozzle orifice which goes into the high speed screw seat. I can't imagine how it got there, but it was obviously there from manufacture. I tried to "seal" it up today, but failed. I'm writing this carb off!
The second carb, which has "Walbro" cast into it, is very different internally to the others. It does not have a replaceable jet. It has a sizeable hole in it which leads directly to the nozzle, via the high speed screw. I couldn't figure out at first why it was having basically the same problem as the other until I pulled out the metering spring. I should note here that this was the first time I had pulled this carb apart, as I had tossed it aside initially and focused on the original one. I could see the spring was different to the Huztl carb and the OEM Walbro also (which I reluctantly pulled apart as well). So I came up with a super basic (and probably flawed) test.
I got my digital scales out. I put the Huztl spring on the scales, standing upright, and then pushed down with my finger to the point that the spring was just fully compressed. The scales read 50 grams of weight. I then tested the OEM spring - 52 grams. Then I tested the China Walbro and the spring read 23 grams! It also didn't look "right". The other springs are a heavier gauge shiny steel, but this one was a dull, galvanised colour and much flimsier.
I swapped the Huztl spring into the China Walbro and installed it on the saw. Fired up, ran perfect. It has a tendency to go rich with a quick throttle blip, but otherwise runs good. I then took it off, because I wanted to mod my "other" Farmertec carb which has been running well on the saw, but at 2 turns out on the high screw. I pulled it apart and it had the same 0.54mm high speed jet. So I drilled it to 0.65mm and put it back together. Back on the saw and it runs really nice. H screw is now at 1.5 turns out.
So I think I have sorted this out. 2 different carbs with an almost identical problem, but from 2 totally different causes!