As you said the grass is very different. Down here in a weeks time the St. Augustine I would cut it at a 5" height and sometimes be cutting 5" or more off. People are anal about their grass. Over fertilizing, over watering, plus we have the summer thunder storms. I always used Rotary high lift blades and paid twice the price for them that my dealer would sell the cheap blades for at his spring and fall clearance sales. I would buy them in the spring and buy the winter time they would be almost worn out so when the dry season started they didn't lift quite as much dirt and dust. I tried the Gators my dealer told me I wouldn't like them. He was right, I should have listened. He would have saved me about $100 for 3 sets of 52" blades. Talk to your dealer he knows what the pros are using and can make an informed decision and help you out.
Down here I would be cutting St. Augustine at one house the next 2 might be Bahia (really rough on blades) and the next house might be Zoysia, my favorite.
I installed fresh blades everyday, worst thing you can do is cut St Augustine with dull blades it tears the grass. Then it's subject to fungus if it rains or gets irrigated early in the evening and sits wet all night. You need a good sharp blade for a smooth cut.