Saw video thread

[huskihl]

Tell them you want specifics of the violation, and tell them if they don't provide it you will file a lawsuit against them for violation of your civil rights!

YouTube is theirs, not ours. I would think it would be a privilege to be able to post there, not a right

 

[huskihl]

@huskihl your turn at termination...

I’m sure

 

[shadco]

@huskihl your turn at termination...

Crap they just sent me a notice that Kevin uploaded a new vidja

.

 

[Deets066]

YouTube is theirs, not ours. I would think it would be a privilege to be able to post there, not a right

Pretty much

 

[MustangMike]

YouTube is theirs, not ours. I would think it would be a privilege to be able to post there, not a right

They all have a set of rules that you have to follow, but they can not take action against you if they can not reasonably say you violated their rules.

They can not just suspend you for no reason, and you have a right to know what the reason is.

If they say you violated their rules, and give an example, not much you can do (even if you disagree), but if they suspend you w/o a reason, you can go after them. They are violating your right to free expression.

 

[Deets066]

They are violating your right to free expression.

I don’t think there’s anything in our constitutional rights about YouTube. Just sayin, it’s a privilege, not a right.

 

[huskihl]

They all have a set of rules that you have to follow, but they can not take action against you if they can not reasonably say you violated their rules.

They can not just suspend you for no reason, and you have a right to know what the reason is.

If they say you violated their rules, and give an example, not much you can do (even if you disagree), but if they suspend you w/o a reason, you can go after them. They are violating your right to free expression.

Idk. I guess I don’t see it like that.

 

[Bigmac]

I agree it’s there product, and if you violate a rule, your cut off, it would be nice if they let people know the reason, but that is there right. I would ask the reason myself. Most people have been having trouble because they didn’t have the “made for kids” setting set up correctly. They have been sending the warnings for a while now.

 

[MustangMike]

You are correct that there is no constitutional right to be able to post videos.

But if someone chooses to operate such a service, and establishes rules, they must also abide by their established rules, or at least have a reasonable basis for their actions.

It becomes a public space, just like (for instance) a restaurant. They can't refuse to serve you just because they don't want to, they must have an appropriate reason for their action.

You may not have any "right" to eat in a restaurant, but once the "public space" has been established, they must have valid reason not to serve you.

You Tube is a public space, not a private club.

 

[Deets066]

You are correct that there is no constitutional right to be able to post videos.

But if someone chooses to operate such a service, and establishes rules, they must also abide by their established rules, or at least have a reasonable basis for their actions.

It becomes a public space, just like (for instance) a restaurant. They can't refuse to serve you just because they don't want to, they must have an appropriate reason for their action.

You may not have any "right" to eat in a restaurant, but once the "public space" has been established, they must have valid reason not to serve you.

You Tube is a public space, not a private club.

Why do you see signs in bars or restaurants that says “we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone”?

 

[Deets066]

Bartender cuts you off...

Fuuck that it’s my right to get another drink, this is a public space.

 

[MustangMike]

Why do you see signs in bars or restaurants that says “we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone”?

Just because a sign is posted does not make it legally enforceable. Lots of signs are posted that are NOT legally enforceable.

That is a judgement the bartender is allowed (and even required) to make because it is deemed to be for the public good (and safety).

 

[Bigmac]

Why do you see signs in bars or restaurants that says “we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone”?

Yep, I have been turned away from playing golf places because I wasn’t wearing a collared shirt, and some places blue jeans won’t cut it, it’s there rules

 

[huskihl]

OK, so the rotten bastages just got me too. How do I know what my URL is? I can’t even access it. Is it just my YouTube name?

 

[sonoransaw]

YouTube is theirs, not ours. I would think it would be a privilege to be able to post there, not a right

True...but when they offer a service and then treat their "customers" unfairly without explanation (throwing out years of investment for no apparent reason), it's tough to just accept as a revoked privilege...

 

[Deets066]

OK, so the rotten bastages just got me too. How do I know what my URL is? I can’t even access it. Is it just my YouTube name?

I suppose I’m not far behind you

 

[redline4]

Just to see what happens, I uploaded this short vid.
I remember setting all my stuff to not for kids when it first came about.
Let's see if I get booted too.

 

[HYPERSAWS]

OK, so the rotten bastages just got me too. How do I know what my URL is? I can’t even access it. Is it just my YouTube name?

Just type in exactly what it says for your url

 

[RI Chevy]

Nice! Doesn't sound moronic. Is it regular traditional carbed?

 

[Armbru84]

Is this the new politics thread? Switch to Vimeo or something else and move on...what I did at this point.